Custom Cookie Cakes

Thick, gooey cookie pies with custom fillings and toppings, baked fresh to order.

Nutley, NJ, USA

Build Your Own Cookie Cake

Custom Cookie Cake - $18

Starting Price

Choose your base, fillings, and toppings to create a cookie cake that's uniquely yours.

A More Personal Way to Celebrate With Dessert

Every cookie cake starts with you. I offer a range of cookie bases from classic chocolate chip to brown butter and everything in between, and then you decide what goes inside and on top. Want brownie chunks mixed in? Salted caramel drizzle? Crushed candy, or a layer of frosting? You're in control, and I handle the baking.

The result is a thick, gooey cookie cake that's baked fresh to your exact specifications. It arrives warm and ready to slice, with every bite tasting like it was made just for this moment. Because it was.

Ideal For

  • People who know exactly what they want and love having a say in the details

  • Special occasions that deserve a dessert as unique as the celebration

  • Anyone craving cookie cake but wanting something beyond the standard options

  • Gifts for fellow dessert lovers who appreciate thoughtful, personalized treats

How It Works

  1. Tell me your vision: Share your cookie base preference, favorite fillings, and dream toppings, or ask for my recommendations if you'd like inspiration.

  2. I bake it fresh: Your custom cookie cake is made to order, baked until it's perfectly thick and gooey, exactly how you like it.

  3. Meet up or have it delivered: Enjoy your creation fresh with a custom arranged delivery date for your special occasion .

About

Cookies with heart

I'm a home baker in Nutley creating custom cookies, cookie pies, and sweet treats for celebrations and everyday moments. Every month brings a new menu of gooey, indulgent flavors, from nostalgic s'mores to decadent peanut butter fudge layers. I work with local customers and beyond, offering free consultations for custom orders and fresh Sunday delivery. What drives me is connecting with my community through baking, supporting other small businesses, and turning simple cookie dough into something people genuinely love.

Services

What I create

Cookie Fudge Pies, XL Bakery Style Cookies, custom orders & party treats.

Party & Event Desserts

Party & Event Desserts

Custom treats for celebrations: cookie bites, brownies, cupcakes, chocolate covered items.

Monthly Menu Cookies

Monthly Menu Cookies

XL bakery-style cookies and seasonal flavors, available for pre-order with local delivery.

Fudge Stuffed Cookie Pie

Fudge Stuffed Cookie Pie

I create decadent fudge-stuffed cookie pies, perfect for sweet cravings and late night munchies.

Gourmet Cookie Pretzels

Gourmet Cookie Pretzels

I craft gourmet stuffed cookie pretzels with premium chocolates, candies, and creative flavor combinations for any occasion.

462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
462 FOLLOWERS
Reviews

(Charleemarie C.)

β€œI tried CoCo Cookies and I'm in love. All desserts are all organic and delicious. This gives me great peace of mind knowing what I'm eating is healthy for me as a breastfeeding mama. Customer service is A+ and delivery is always on time. If you have not already tried order ANY of these wonderful sweet treats - they do NOT disappoint”

Frequently Asked Questions

Contact

Get in Touch

Let me know what you're craving and I'll help bring your sweet idea to life.

@luisangelbaez2

@luisangelbaez2

What have you doneπŸ˜‚

@doughxhoney

@doughxhoney

Yeah this is next level πŸ”₯

@daily.epicure

@daily.epicure

😍

@withlove.nini

@withlove.nini

This is beautiful πŸ₯ΉπŸ˜

@suescavone

@suescavone

I loved these!

@milenab994

@milenab994

😍