Fudge Stuffed Cookie Pie
By the Slice
By the Slice
This is the ultimate indulgence for anyone who can't choose between cookies and fudge.
A More Personal Way to Satisfy Your Sweet
Our fudge stuffed cookie pies are started with a gooey cookie base loaded with chocolate chips, studded throughout with pockets of smooth, rich fudge that melts on your tongue. Every slice delivers that perfect moment when warm cookie meets cool fudge, creating a textural contrast that makes each bite feel special. The pie is baked to order, so you get that fresh-from-the-oven warmth and aroma that makes the experience even more memorable.
I use premium chocolate and quality butter to ensure the fudge is silky and the cookie is tender without being cakey. The result is a dessert that's substantial enough to share but so good you might want to keep it all to yourself. Whether you're celebrating a milestone, treating yourself, or impressing guests, this pie delivers the kind of comfort that only homemade baking can provide.
Ideal For
Chocolate enthusiasts who want an over-the-top dessert experience
Special occasions and celebrations that call for something memorable
Sharing with family or friends who appreciate quality baking
Anyone craving that perfect balance of chewy and fudgy
How It Works
Place Your Order: Choose your preferred delivery or pickup date, and let me know if you have any preferences or dietary considerations.
I Bake Fresh: Your pie slice is made to order using premium ingredients, ensuring peak freshness and flavor.
Enjoy: Pick up fresh or have it delivered, then slice and savor every decadent bite.
Cookies with heart
I'm a home baker in Nutley creating custom cookies, cookie pies, and sweet treats for celebrations and everyday moments. Every month brings a new menu of gooey, indulgent flavors, from nostalgic s'mores to decadent peanut butter fudge layers. I work with local customers and beyond, offering free consultations for custom orders and fresh Sunday delivery. What drives me is connecting with my community through baking, supporting other small businesses, and turning simple cookie dough into something people genuinely love.
What I create
Cookie Fudge Pies, XL Bakery Style Cookies, custom orders & party treats.
Custom Cookie Cakes
Thick, gooey cookie pies with custom fillings and toppings, baked fresh to order.
Party & Event Desserts
Custom treats for celebrations: cookie bites, brownies, cupcakes, chocolate covered items.
Monthly Menu Cookies
XL bakery-style cookies and seasonal flavors, available for pre-order with free local delivery.
Gourmet Cookie Pretzels
I craft gourmet stuffed cookie pretzels with premium chocolates, candies, and creative flavor combinations for any occasion.
Holiday Specials
During the fall and winter season, I create festive custom cookie cakes and sweet treats for your holiday celebrations.
Customer Reviews
“had the cutest and tastiest cookie cake for my 35th birthday from coco cookie cakes. Everyone loved it so much I did another one for Christmas !”
“I tried CoCo Cookies and I'm in love. All desserts are all organic and delicious. This gives me great peace of mind knowing what I'm eating is healthy for me as a breastfeeding mama. Customer service is A+ and delivery is always on time. If you have not already tried order ANY of these wonderful sweet treats - they do NOT disappoint”
“Had Coco Cookies for my son's first birthday and it was a complete hit! 2 months later & everyone is still talking about how delicious they were the best cookies around!”
Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Have questions about ordering custom cookies and sweet treats? Browse our most common questions below to learn more about how we work with our customers.
What My Customers Say
I love hearing from people who've enjoyed my custom cookies and sweet treats. Here's what my customers are saying about their orders and experiences.
Get in Touch
Let me know what you're craving and I'll help bring your sweet idea to life.